Showing posts with label Films: WHC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Films: WHC. Show all posts

Thursday, April 23, 2009

RECENT STUFF

1. 'Vacate the personae.'
Having made it finally through Saul Bellow’s Humboldt’s Gift (1975), I breathe an immense sigh of relief. The book was almost as exhausting as The Adventures of Augie March (1953) and that’s saying something. Bellow is the kind of writer, I now know for sure, that can lay it on with a trowel. Charles Citrine, the first person narrator, like all Bellow narrators, is a pretty interesting guy to be around; Bellow makes him a literary celebrity in the Chicago area, and is endlessly fascinated with the kinds of wheelings and dealings such a guy (like Bellow himself) has to get involved with to keep the money flowing, no matter how many prizes he may have won and whose good graces he may be in at the moment.

I knew of the novel as the one with the character, Von Humboldt Fleisher, based on the poet Delmore Schwartz, but I really had the impression, going in, that we were going to be treated to Bellow’s fictionalized version of Schwartz’s story. Sorta, not quite. Humboldt never really has center stage: he gets his due early on with some great scenes of how rapturously wonderful he was in Charlie’s eyes early on and how much bad blood came into the relationship due to Humboldt’s later instability, but the novel -- complete with a rather unpredictable and even deus ex machina-like smalltime mafioso named Cantabile, and a femme moyen sensuelle (and quite sensual) who ditches Charlie late in the book, for a mortician no less, and an ex-wife who is mostly offstage but who is a sinkhole of monetary demands, and an old flame, and the daughter of said flame, and a brother about to undergo heart-bypass surgery (one of the best encounters in the book) -- rambles all over and is in no hurry to get anywhere particularly. Add to all that the fact that Charlie is sorta, maybe, kinda converting his thinking to the ideas of Rudolph Steiner, and you get an odd double vision in the latter stages of the book. For all the narrative’s endless interest in whatever is happening and whoever is making it happen, the narrator is ostensibly trying to divest himself of his passionate regard for those things he cannot change. He’s searching for wisdom; again: maybe. Citrine is too canny, too much embroiled in the quotidian and all its quirks to be believable as sage-on-the-mountain material, but Bellow does have some of the goods on show. There is a sense that all this earnest investigation of everything is meant to show that, wherever it may rest, the heart is deluding itself if it thinks its attachments can ever be a raison d’être for actual existence. There’s more to things than meets the eye. But it’s not as if Citrine is a seeker 'against a backdrop' of literary fortunes, mafia threats, and a sudden reinstatement of fortune via an improbable filmscript cooked up long ago with Humboldt, for Citrine is always swallowed up by the demands the world -- and all the people in it -- make on him. Like I said, exhausting.

2. Ah, ma patrie

The final screening of the semester for Cinema at the Whitney was a double feature of films by Jean-Pierre Melville, The Silence of the Sea (1947) and Army of Shadows (1969), both engaged by the situation of the Nazi occupation of France in WWII. The first is an extremely static tale that unfolds like an old French conte -- the arrival of a foreigner and how he became a part of our provincial lives -- but with the difference that the foreigner is a Nazi officer staying at the rural home of an old Frenchman, the narrator, and his young niece. Plenty of fireside monologues during which the Nazi officer -- with cultivated, genteel aplomb -- holds forth on his love for France. Though, as unwilling hosts, the man and his niece never speak to and barely acknowledge the presence of the officer, all hearts soften toward this well-meaning conqueror who speaks not of how Germany will alter France but rather how the civilizing influence of France will transform the Huns into . . . well, not Nazis, apparently, but something that history would be proud of, defined by even. Boy, is he in for a surprise when he finally realizes the intentions of his Nazi brethern! And so he goes back to the front rather than take part in the further humiliation of la belle France. Beautifully shot, composed, with a steady pacing that is almost hypnotic, the film amounts essentially to a sentimental ‘my country, ’tis of thee’ paen, understandable, given the palpable anger against the Occupation, but still weak in anything like a nuanced rendering of the situation. Beautiful clichés of both countries are presented, but with much less affecting emotional bond than is found in Renoir’s Grand Illusion (1937), so much more telling in its depiction of the code of officers being undermined by the realities of war.

Army of Shadows presents us with a more ostensibly realistic depiction of a cell of resisters to the Occupation, and has many memorable scenes, most gripping of which is the determination to put to death a traitor who the resistance group has abducted. They aren’t prepared for suddenly having neighbors on the other side of the wall who will hear everything -- so no guns, and no knives. And so the man must be strangled to death while all participate in holding him motionless. In Melville’s hands, the scene is almost humorous, at least in the initial failure to be properly prepared and in being so incompetent in their fell purpose, but it finally becomes definitive of what makes for solidarity: the necessity of dealing death to the enemy. The film does run on, though, and Melville’s pacing is at times truly strange, as though he has no particular interest in getting the tale told. The film has a rather flabby feel to it, rather than a taut arc that will take us to the ultimate fate of the cell -- some dead by capture, some dead as traitors, the majority left to those ‘after the film’ summaries of their ultimate fates that are always so unsatisfying.

And that’s part of the problem: one finally asks: what is this film the story of? Is it meant to show some gradual moral change or crisis in the group? Some kind of self-questioning? That does happen when the one female in the group, Mathilde, played with haughty calm by Simone Signoret, betrays the group, after capture, to save her daughter from a fate worse than death as a whore to a Polish regiment, and the group has to overcome the protests of one of their number that he won’t stand for her execution. They shoot her dead on the street and then the film quickly ends. But to get to that moment, if that is meant to be defining, we have to wander though many scenes that seem much looser than need be (including one failed attempt to rescue a comrade who is near death anyway, that simply seems comical in its incompetence, again), and a rescue of Philippe Gerbier, the figure we’ve been following since the beginning, that is almost outrageously successful.

My feeling watching the film was that I’d be watching it for the rest of my life since its pacing was so much like life: things happen, and then something else does, or doesn’t. Even so, the film was fascinating if only because I loved seeing the locations, the people, the actors who weren’t trying to be charming stars, but at the same time I couldn’t stop myself from conjuring images of much more exciting, Hollywood versions of fateful missions (The Dirty Dozen, 1967) and risky escapes (The Great Escape, 1963). Released in 1969, Army of Shadows is perhaps far enough away from the events of the Resistance to be able to take some liberties for entertainment purposes?

3. Calvino Revisited

Just for fun I re-read Italo Calvino’s If On a Winter’s Night a Traveler (1979), which I first read some time in the early ‘80s and was enchanted by. What’s more, my memory of the novel has always been a reference point whenever anyone discusses fictional sleight-of-hand, as with Borges, or Cortázar, or Barth, or what-have-you. Calvino’s version of fictions that fold in on themselves provides a send-up of the reader’s dependence on a text -- a text that is never simply an object -- while at the same time conjuring the extent to which people become the texts they read or write.

One could say it’s a novel that treats the status of being ‘a reader’ as a certain kind of identity, a defining characteristic, and Calvino is charming in his evocation of the oddly personal communality of that status. What’s more he’s willing to put that very relation -- his interaction with his own readers -- at stake by treating us as hopelessly hooked on whatever he chooses to do with his narrative, which involves several ‘short stories,’ or tales within the tale, that comprise the opening pages of the novel we (or rather, ‘you,’ dear reader) are attempting to read. In other words, we read with a second-person character who is reading a series of openings to novels we never get to finish because something always happens to the text. These proferred novels are of a variety of types and are almost equally interesting, as far as they go, but they are also meant to be page-turners of a sort, things we won’t put down till we see how it all comes out. And we won’t ever know. The story of what keeps happening to interrupt our reading is the story that ‘you’ are engaged in: involving another reader (an attractive and arguably more knowledgeable female counterpart to the masculine ‘you’ of the story), the other reader’s sister, an Ian Fleming-like novelist, and a novelistic forger. It all ends with our happy couple -- you, the reader, and your female counterpart, the Other Reader -- settled in bed together as you finish If On a Winter’s Night a Traveler by Italo Calvino.

Fictional closure is where real life begins, but what Calvino grasps so well, and perpetrates his fiction on the premise of, is that the Reader only wants fictions to go on and on. Maybe so, but he wisely brings his to a close before the proliferation of openings becomes tiring, and before the characters, who never really are characters, seem too lacking in particularity to interest us. Why I loved the novel is that he maintains its pace well and builds up its comedy through a readerly frustration it expects us to enjoy. But also because it seemed to me that at the heart of such fiction is a clear-eyed appraisal of the ruse of fiction, of how it applies conventions to give us ‘the reality effect’ it aims for, and how, mutatis mutandis, all such details can easily be something else, if only we are reading a different kind of story with different conventions. The reality is all in the eye, so to speak, or, even more to the point, all in the terms, the language, the conventions of depiction that we trust to render what we find ourselves in the midst of. Without that, we have only opposing subjective ‘takes’ -- otherwise known as politics -- and Calvino archly sees that ultimately politics in art is a blow against the art, or artifice, itself. A refusal to be led, to be told, to suspend disbelief, or, worse, skeptical engagement with any world other than the one one knows to be the case. I saw Calvino’s approach as a great joke -- but without malice -- on all those who want to lose reality in a fiction, but also all those who can’t abide a fiction that doesn’t correspond to ‘reality.’ Bravo, Calvino!

Wednesday, April 1, 2009

SALUTE TO STANLEY

'How did he do it, how did he become Stanley Kubrick?' I found myself wondering that last Friday night as I watched The Killing (1956), a film directed by Kubrick early in his career, screened as part of a mini retrospect at Yale’s Cinema at the Whitney, to honor the director at the tenth anniversary of his death. A B-movie all the way, it’s got minor character actors (Sterling Hayden and Elisha Cook, Jr. are the biggest names in the cast); it’s got that low budget 'hard-bitten' look to it, and it suffers from the bane of the ‘50s film, the need to have some corny resolution that stops Hayden’s character from getting away with it. Enter poodle to make suitcase full of money fall onto the airport tarmac, open, and cause bucks to blow away. I kid you not. Treasure of the Sierra Madre it ain’t.

Seeing The Killing on the big screen at Yale sorta made it seem important and of course if it is it’s because it’s early Kubrick. And what exactly is the claim to fame of Kubrick? In other words, asking how Kubrick became Kubrick also presupposes the question of who or what Kubrick is. And the answer becomes clearer when you see some of the early work. Kubrick is the American film director who managed somehow to make masterpieces of genre films, films that fit into categories overrun by numerous B-level productions.

Kubrick was not an 'arthouse film maker'; he had no interest in creating films that would only be appreciated by intellectuals and cineastes and aesthetes. And one way to avoid that fate is to make films in popular genres: The Killing is a heist film; 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968; shown on Saturday night with the film’s star Keir Dullea on hand to talk about the experience) is a sci-fi movie; Full Metal Jacket (1987) is a Vietnam War movie; The Shining (1980) is a horror film. Others -- like Lolita (1962) and A Clockwork Orange (1971) -- are film adaptations of notorious novels; Barry Lyndon is a period film; Dr. Strangelove (1964) is a slapstick black comedy; Eyes Wide Shut (1999) is, I believe, Kubrick’s version of a romantic comedy.

The other film screened Friday night -- Paths of Glory (1957) -- is a bit more mixed in its genre: a war film that becomes a trial film, while at the same time being an even more devastating critique of the military than Strangelove. It’s the film where certain trademark elements of the Kubrick visual style begin to manifest themselves: like tracking shots through corridors, or, in this case, trenches; like important moments depicted in long shot; like close ups as moments of truth; but, even so, we’re not yet at the breakthrough that was and is 2001.

That film is a film like no other. Unforgettable, influential, breathtaking, mind-bending, yes, but also classical. The pacing of the film -- its epic unfolding -- must be something Kubrick learned from making Spartacus (1960; what used to be called 'the swords and sandals' genre), even though he disowned the film because he wasn’t given final cut. 2001 moves even more slowly than Spartacus if such a thing is possible, but the difference is that every frame of 2001 is loaded with portent, is a meditation on shapes and space. It’s pop art minimalism come to the big screen, and the story – featuring certain well-worn sci fi cliches like the machine that runs amok, and the secret mission that is more fearsome than expected, and the alien life form that causes us to question 'life as we know it' -- veers off into space age psychedelia with the trappings of Nietzschean metaphysics. Wow, man. Some on hand Saturday referred to viewers of the film who claimed a religious experience while watching it.

But is the film dated? Only in its late ‘60s attempt to imagine the 21st century -- in terms of style and in terms of a geopolitics where Russia and the U.S. are still the big guns in space exploration as they were in the ‘60s. But in some ways the film is wonderfully prescient: the computer HAL (acronym for ‘heuristic’ and ‘algorithmic’) would no doubt get along wonderfully with today’s counterpart CADIE (Cognitive Autoheuristic Distributed-Intelligence Entity). But what makes the film magnificent is its direction -- the way that Kubrick’s eye and ear (amazing cinematography and soundtrack) dominates a world he largely constructed himself. It’s an essay in cinematic make-believe and sleight-of-hand with no computer-generated effects and with still the most convincing evocation of space travel ever presented.

After Friday night’s screening I watched on DVD the first part of Barry Lyndon (1975) and on Saturday night, part two. At various times in watching that film -- both on its release and in subsequent screenings and on the small screen -- I have felt that its distinctive distancing from the pacing and editing of other ‘70s films could be said to work to its disadvantage. In other words, I tended to be sympathetic to those who find the film 'too slow,' or 'too minimal in dialogue and action,' which most accept in 2001, because of its manifest originality, but not for a tale of an 18th century Irish upstart and ne’er-do-well. But watching it this time I felt it might be in a sense Kubrick’s most personal film.

Barry Lyndon is a timeless rendering of the early modern period that, unlike the future of 2001 or Clockwork Orange, never dates, and, unlike the settings of his other films, doesn’t suffer from the imagery that makes a film contemporaneous with its era. Barry Lyndon recreates the 18th century as represented by master painters of that era; it is the closest any film comes to inhabiting a world that existed long ago. The films that were its contemporaries, with rare exceptions, seem like effects of their time while Barry Lyndon remains closed in a time capsule, a living museum. That effect has been criticized (every era likes to believe its daily anxieties and joys are ignored by art at its peril), but the film stands now as a singular achievement. Which, as a phrase, sums up Kubrick’s career as well as anything I can think of.

Friday, February 27, 2009

WHERE THE BOYS WERE

Last night the WHC featured a well-paired double feature I couldn't resist: John Cassavetes' Husbands (1970) and Hal Ashby's The Last Detail (1973). Both films feature a trio of men and the dynamic that evolves amongst them during what could be called 'a bender.' In the Cassavetes film, the fun begins after the funeral for the fourth member of the jolly band, but is prolonged when the three buddies, Harry (Ben Gazzara), Gus (Cassavetes), Archie (Peter Falk) go to London together: Harry because he's just become estranged from his wife, the other two as moral support. In Ashby's film, two 'lifers' in the Navy, 'Badass' Buddusky (Jack Nicholson) and 'Mule' Mulhall (Otis Young) are given the detail of escorting young kleptomaniac Meadows (Randy Quaid) to Portsmouith, MA, where he will be incarcerated for eight years.

In other words, the boys in Husbands bond as one of their number is 'sprung' -- first, from life, via death, second, from wedlock via an erratic path of self-indulgence and occasional violence. While the boys in Detail bond while trying to introduce self-indulgence to one of their number who is about to lose all freedoms.

The guys in Husbands are a bit older; settled, married, family men, so the need to let loose is simply a given. We do see Gazzara trying to make amends with his wife -- which features her pulling a kitchen knife on him, and him slapping and man-handling both his wife and mother-in-law -- but otherwise the families are simply in the background as the world forever in the periphery of whatever husbands might be doing at the moment. What makes the film so appealing is the naturalness of the actors -- Falk, Gazzara, and Cassavetes are friends and their interactions seem spontaneous, much of their dialogue at times feeling improvised, the way real friends josh each other, take exception over trivial things like certain verbal or facial expressions, bond affectionately on moments just as fleeting, and generally create a collectivity that unites them against the world, even if, among themselves, there is real doubt and a lot of uncertain longings. Gazzara's Harry is the most 'troubled' -- in the sense of dissatisfied with his life, but also in the sense of having a personality that seems to bristle simply because that's his nature. Falk's Archie is the funniest; his efforts to pick up women, particularly an older, 'madam'-looking woman in a casino in London, would be simply sad if he weren't somehow so likeably incompetent. Then there's Cassavetes' Gus who is fascinatingly mercurial in his interactions; there's the sense that his patience is always being tested, always on edge, which translates into a feeling of his intense attachment to these fellows, despite everything. The film is wise, wry, knowing, affectionate but clear-eyed, showing us the kind of hollow underbelly of the midlingly successful breadwinner of the period without a lot of posturing about it. It feels like spending time with guys you might find drinking in any bar in town at any time. In the end you know them a bit better for having drunk with them and gone to the places they go, and for having seen them 'behind closed doors' with the women they pick up in London, but you don't really know them that well because they really don't know themselves or each other all that well either.

The guys in Last Detail are thrown together by chance and necessity, which gives the film more immediate drama right from the start. Neither Badass or Mule wants to be on the detail, and Meadows is a clueless, pathetic, but goofily likeable klepto who is facing a harsh reprimand simply for trying to rip off a polio collection box. But Nicholson's Badass, noticeably shorter than Mule and the towering, gawky Meadows, as the somewhat stereotypical sailor looking for a good time, is a telling portrait of a man's man, trying to do a decent job of older mate showing the youngun a good time: telling, because Nicholson exposes us to Badass' masculine bragging, his manly charm, his sense of the thrill and allure of violence, his love of drinking, his savvy sense of his place in the world, his generous feelings toward his charge, his pity for the boy mixed with his disgust at the boy's docility toward his fate, and even his schadenfreude at the hapless kid's plight. The moment of insight comes when Badass tells Mule that the kid won't run off because, deep down, he's glad he's going to jail. Out in the world anything that would happen to him would be mostly bad; now, the worst has already happened and that's a relief. The moment of truth comes when Meadows tries to run off in the 11th hour, his growth beyond the pathetic victim Badass read him as, correctly, having occurred under Badass' tutelage.

Both films show us something about the dynamics of male bonding: in Husbands, because these men have families, the bond is based on asserting a hold upon the identity of guys free to do what guys want to do -- drinking, sports, gambling, picking up girls. In Last Detail, the bond is the Navy: it makes Badass and Mule equals, if not friends, and it makes their sympathy with Meadows not personal so much as institutional: he is the uncertain young recruit they might have felt in themselves once upon a time, or at least is a type they have seen before, only now they can try to intervene, to show him what life is all about: getting drunk, going to a party, going to a whorehouse, and so on. The party is the funniest part: there, a number of vaguely counter-cultural early '70s types clash memorably with the working-class bluntness and social allegiances of Badass and Mule. There the greenness of Meadows is to his advantage because he's a type who could be recruited for anything, such as the Hare Krishna chanting he picks up in a New York temple and which acts as his entree to the counter-culture party.

What both films manage is avoiding the 'bittersweet' tag that often lands on such efforts to present both the harshness and the affection of such interactions. Both are better than that in refusing the kinds of moves toward ersatz emotional catharsis (aka sappiness) that have become de rigeur in American movies in the Spielberg era. In that sense, both films kindle a nostalgia for '70s indies: both Cassavetes and Ashby were outsiders to the Hollywood system, treating its execs with disdain and avoiding the kinds of 'improvements' that would spell bigger box office. And that fact also creates a bond between a certain audience and these aging boys.

Monday, February 2, 2009

CINEMAGIC

Recent viewings: on Saturday at WHC, two films by the silent film master Erich von Stroheim, Foolish Wives (1922) and The Wedding March (1928), then on Sunday, instead of the Super Bowl, I finally sat down with David Lynch's Inland Empire (2006), which was "filmed" in digital video.

And what went through my mind, wonderingly, as I watched the completely silent Foolish Wives (not even a score since that would've made the film play at a faster speed) was admiration for the ability to tell a story without words. There were the title cards, certainly, both as narration and as dialogue -- the narration titles were often rather amusing in their disjointed scene-setting -- but much of the fascination of the film derived solely from the act of watching. And what I admired was that von Stroheim had such a complete grasp of his medium that he was able to keep us focused on whatever scene was before us.

I realized that much of that fascination had to do with watching "dumb show." In other words, just as when we observe people at a distance in real life, we have to interpret what's going on solely by what we see. So we have to remain attentive so as not to miss something. And von Stroheim has an easy, superb naturalness in his way of keeping our attention on what he wants to show us. But it's a method that has to know exactly how every scene should be shot and how played. Top it off with the fact that Stroheim was himself the male lead in both films: in one film, heartless; in the other, forced to become heartless. In both cases, the story of how that plays out is faultless in its pacing, its sets, its grasp of how to communicate with the audience.

Von Stroheim is known as the man who made Greed, a 21 reel film that would've taken about eight to nine hours to watch. All but two hours' worth was destroyed by the studio. Would it be possible to make a fully watchable film at that length? I can believe von Stroheim did it, and it suggests possibilities of a film that would truly feel like a novel in its plots and subplots and diversity.

Watching Inland Empire after the von Stroheim films convinced me that might in fact be an idea worth pursuing. Shooting in digital video rather than film means no one can destroy the stock, no one has to pay for processing, so one can be as prolix as one likes. This could be a great danger in creating a sprawling, pointless opus which, no doubt, some find Inland Empire to be. But what this kind of license -- the film runs to 179 minutes -- requires, for justification, is no less a compelling grasp of the medium than von Stroheim shows.

Lynch is a master at delineating his own dream world universe. Inland Empire shows possibilities for what an "art film" can be once we no longer have the driving logic of narrative continuity to buttress what we're seeing. Lynch has often strayed into this realm, but his movies have tended to downplay the possible breaks with narrative norms in favor of "a story." Inland Empire instead creates "a world." Rather than try to follow narrative progress, we follow narrative juxtaposition. This bit of the world set against this other bit of the world. There is great beauty, humor, drama, and a very unsettling, almost metaphysical suspense, as though at any moment the very borders of sanity were being skirted.

But what makes Inland Empire work is the same thing that makes Foolish Wives work: a complete grasp of how to portray action, how to make it live on the screen, how to create and sustain our interest in watching by constantly giving us something interesting to watch. Von Stroheim tells a story one could easily recap; Lynch tells a story that one can only sum up, scene by scene. But both rely entirely on what the eye registers in watching. The effect is always in excess of what a description of the scene would provide. And that, my friends, is cinemagic.

Sunday, December 21, 2008

FILM CLIPS, 2

Wham Bam

A 2008 release new to DVD that I've just seen: Wanted, directed by Timur Bekmambetov (no slouch of a name!) and starring the always capable James McAvoy as a working geek, somewhat in the manner of Ed Norton in The Fight Club (1999), until one day all hell breaks lose and, shazam!, turns out he's the scion of a super assassin, and gets to do the whole "train me till I break or make one of you" routine at the hands of a secret fraternity, complete with a sexy female, played by the ever-chiseled Angelina Jolie, named Fox (kinda ... says it all), and some other badass dudes, while Morgan Freeman stands around looking stoically sage, or sagely stoic. It all goes wrong in several right ways -- meaning that which side is bad and which good gets mixed up, but our hero manages to keep his head on straight. To its credit, the film just keeps moving with one of the more inventive car chase / shoot outs I can recall; it's also fun to catch glimpses of real Chicago in all the wildly improbable razza-ma-tazz. Basically it's a movie with characters who seem to occupy a video game, what with bending bullets and other kinds of Matrixy stunts. So, yeah, Fight Club meets Spider Man meets The Matrix in a video game. Just what the teen in us wanted.

WHC 'n' me

And for "Obscure Film I Never Heard Of That I'm Glad I Saw," the award goes to . . . Nothing But a Man (1964), directed by Michael Roemer, about Duff, an average black guy working for the railroad in Alabama who falls for a preacher's daughter slash school teacher, but runs afoul of the local Jim Crow status quo; he's also got a no-account drunken father whom he barely knows shambling around Birmingham. The cast is comprised mainly of non-professional actors (though a young Japhet Koto is one of the surly railroad workers), but that means that Abbey Lincoln (a singer who plays the preacher's daughter) and Julius Harris (a registered nurse who plays Duff's dad) get to shine with performances that manage to imbue somewhat hackneyed parts (even in 1964) with grace and power and believable depth. The "hackneyed" slur could easily doom this film, except that its unassuming naturalness -- everything in it seems manifestly real rather than a set -- keeps before us, without hammering it or going for the extended schmaltz with which Hollywood tends to play up its "social concerns," that these are simply black people trying to live normal lives. In the world of 1964 that was a radical idea: that black folk were "no different" and should be able to live like anyone else, on equal footing. And it's that point that the film's director nicely underscored in his comments after the screening: to even show on screen a black couple in intimate close-up together was crossing a taboo. In other words, the somewhat static camera and the overuse of close-up and tight compositions serves a purpose, so that we can't try to distance ourselves from the basic human frustration these characters face against the restrictions and impositions of a society that can't accept equality. The film is so gentle and restrained and yet, ultimately, so dignified about what it wants to say that it reminds one of good documentary-making where the point of it all is made by the clarity with which the scenes are put together. And at this remove in time, even the film's hokeyness, here and there, is kind of endearing.

Another film shown at WHC this semester along these lines -- of depicting average people in such a way as to illuminate their lives' quiet dignity -- was Yosujiro Ozu's Tokyo Story (1953). This touching story of an elderly couple from a provincial town visiting their successful children in Tokyo, children who in the economic progress post-WWII have little real connection to their elders, works because of the understated bond of the older couple. One could search for a word to describe it: affection, commitment, love, tenacity -- but what those words don't get across, but the actors do, is how life with someone, for decades, becomes a taken-for-granted togetherness that works because it requires no proofs or demonstrations. When the wife/mother dies at the end, we get to see how self-absorbed her children are, but the film doesn't condemn them -- like their father, it accepts that that's how the young are. It's only the widow of the son who died in the war who truly empathizes with the old man, seeing the loss that the children would prefer not to notice. What makes the film so extraordinary is that it isn't sentimental or unsparing; it's as if it has no message at all. This is simply what some people lived through, it seems to say -- but in the context of the post-WWII world, and there are many shots of the urban world and many comments on how things are changing, what these people were living through is significant, and the film lets you grasp that without underscoring it unduly.

It seems that most of my viewing this semester at WHC fell into the "neo-realism" category. Another worthwhile screening was Fellini's seminal Nights of Cabiria (1957). For me, "Fellini" is always the Fellini of La Dolce Vita (1960) and 8 ½ (1963), but this film is effective for, in neo-realist fashion, depicting the underclass with genuine interest and fascination, not simply looking at "sordid" lives for the thrill of the sordid. It manages to create a varied and fascinating backdrop to the episodic vignettes that comprise a period of time in the life of the prostitute Cabiria. Played by Fellini's wife Giulietta Masina, Cabiria is a tour de force of expressive faces and physical gestures and movement. She's been likened to a female Chaplin, and rightly so. Like Chaplin's Tramp she is always more sinned against than sinning and is naive and pathetic in a winsome way. But unlike Chaplin, she can also be vituperative, egotistical, and somewhat callous. But in Fellini's case, the judgments aren't aimed at Cabiria but at the world she inhabits, with its frenzied religious rituals; destitute people living in caves visited by a single good Samaritan; rich, bored movie star and angry, then repentant girlfriend; coarser whores than Cabiria, who maintains an almost bourgeois sense of dignity; and heartless predators who woo the unsuspecting Cabiria, who never seems to learn from her misadventures, and then rob her. The film is ultimately unsatisfying because its only response to Cabiria's final predicament is to show life and high spirits going on -- which does revive Cabiria herself, but that revival is purely cinematic. And it's that insight, I believe, that sets Fellini off into his greatest achievements in understanding what cinema, as artifice, is all about.

While I admire the neo-realist efforts here and the documentary aesthetic, it seems to me that cinema as artifice is something a true artist of the medium must confront -- if only because of that tendency, as in Wanted, to keep pushing the envelope of what appears "real" on screen. Now that nothing does (or anything does -- same thing), it's good to go back and see films like Roemer's, Ozu's, '60s Fellini to see that there was a time when film might be as "real" as a Chekhov story or a newsreel. Really.

Monday, May 5, 2008

WORLD WAR II REVISITED

World War II has been the setting of so many films, it seems dangerous terrain for a filmmaker attempting anything new. We could say that perhaps about any genre that has had a long life and that continues to interest, but in the case of WWII films the early versions seemed to determine expectations about the boys -- from all over this great country (“hey Iowa, have you met Brooklyn here?”) -- and the hardships they faced (“Captain, the men haven’t had a decent meal in two months”) and the untimely deaths they met (“he was right here a minute ago, talking to me about his girl back home, and now he’s–”), to say nothing of the cliché of the tough-as-nails commander who either sees the error of his ways only at the cost of his platoon, or proves to his men they can take more than they ever believed they could; then there’s the sensitive leader, the gutsy malcontent, the oddly detached and therefore somewhat spiritual enlisted man, maybe a blood-thirsty eager killer or two, the romantic with the girl back home, the brainy kid who just wants to be one of the guys, the determined suck-up and rah-rah, the ethnic folk hero type, the cowardly leader, etc., etc. Not even the Western has as many stereotypes and stock characters, and not even the Western is as emphatically a man’s world, guys only affair.

So, you sense my skepticism toward the idea of a great WWII film? Or, put another way, a “great” WWII film would have all those familiar elements of the genre but somehow “transcend” them with something new. I don’t know that Terrence Malick’s The Thin Red Line (1998), which was screened at the WHC last Monday, manages to do that, but at least it tries and sometimes succeeds. One reason it succeeds as much as it does is because of casting and acting. In war pictures like this one, there are a lot of characters, a lot of little stories, and you’ve got to have actors -- what used to be called “character actors” -- able to pull off their given bit in the whole. The cast on-hand for TRL is impressive and they’re able to push these familiar GI Joes into somewhat new terrain. As the most dramatic untimely death, Woody Harrelson is riveting, as the irascible Lt. Col. Tall, Nick Nolte is full-bore Nolte -- perhaps his greatest scenery-chewing role ever; as the sensitive Capt. Staros, Elias Koteas acquits himself well, and as the spiritual, detached Pvt. Witt, James Caviezel has the face of an impassive idol, and Sean Penn, as the gutsy malcontent, 1st Sgt. Welsh, simply has a face -- rugged, good-looking but not too, expressive, wry, inward -- that belongs here, that could’ve made a career of this genre in an earlier era.

The other reason the film succeeds is cinematography: John Toll’s swooping runs with the men through high grass and up hills, the feel of the bombardment as a chaos of movement and noise, the perspective shots of characters at key moments, the judicious use of slow motion (not overused as it so often is in action movies), as for instance the almost dreamlike scene when the GIs finally overtake the Japanese camp, and the pervading sense of natural beauty and mystery even in conjunction with such violence and horror.

What I’m not quite sure succeeds is the overarching meaning of the film. As the most harrowing WWII movie I’ve ever seen, TRL deserves its place in a film-buff Hall of Fame, but as a movie with its own logic and meaning -- a film set in WWII rather than a film “about” WWII -- it’s less clear what we’re dealing with. The pacing is epic, the intro in the Solomon Islands, where “the gentle savages” live their childlike lives in what looks a natural Eden, are a bit tendentious in opposition to the war scenes, as though we should all wish to “go AWOL” from the 20th century and go back to our noble savage roots in nature, and the relationships among the men, such as they are, don’t really resonate. Most characters seem a bit monadic, in their own worlds of struggle and strife and death, so that the scenes which matter most are the truly intense exchanges: Nolte bawling out Koteas; Nolte getting sensitive himself and revealing his motives, in a bid for bonding, with John Cusack; Caviezel offering consolation to Harrelson during his death throes; the brief and somewhat enigmatic exchanges between Penn and Caviezel. These things stay with one after the film is over, but even more does the control of the action -- the narrating presence, as it were -- impress one with its determined command and its idiosyncratic emphases. Malick is an oddly self-possessed filmmaker and he has given us an oddly compelling account of the battle of Guadalcanal that seems leavened with a kind of grandiose, spacey clarity -- and if that phrase sounds a bit like an oxymoron, that’s as it should be because the film is a bit overwhelming, and I can’t recall the last film I saw that I’d say that about.

Sunday, April 13, 2008

APRIL FOOLS

The first of April has acquired some significance for me, in part because it's the date dedicated to my favorite Tarot card, The Fool -- which is also the name of the rock group on whose album cover Pynchon's Tyrone Slothrop is supposedly visible in the background -- and the date has meaning in Gravity's Rainbow because of the fact that in 1945 Easter and April Fool's Day were the same day. Apart from that, there's the use I make of the date in Between Days, which may or may not be tied to those other associations I just mentioned.

April Fool's this year I went to hear Terry Eagleton of Oxford give the first of four lectures at Yale. It seemed an appropriate date because Eagleton seemed only too eager to play the fool, jibing at an opponent he designated as Ditchens -- an amalgamation of Richard Dawkins and Christopher Hitchens for their recent publications in favor of atheism -- so as to establish that liberals who associate Christianity with conservatism are wrong. For Eagleton, Christianity is the faith of the downtrodden, of the have-nots, those he was willing to call -- from the point of view of capitalist success stories -- losers. Christ, of course, being the ultimate Holy Fool, Eagleton's point was perhaps worth expressing, given the day, all the more so when Eagleton's purpose was itself so quixotic. Invoking Nietzsche (the figure I associate most readily with The Fool card), Eagleton said that it was indeed foolish to attempt to save Christianity from Christendom, from the misappropriation of the religion by those who have agendas rather less than Christlike. But that left him not much to bring by way of insight. No matter, it was enough for him, apparently, to spoof what he termed the liberal intelligentsia as a way of yet again establishing his more radical-than-thou credentials. It was fitting then to see him, like Christ denied thrice, pause three times in his Thursday lecture, expecting laughs that didn't come. Not quite fool enough, our Terry. I didn't get to hear his lectures the subsequent week, but I'd already had reason enough to expect that it would be the flayed body of Marx that would rise again on the third day.

After the second lecture, I went to see a screening of Charles Ferguson's documentary on the Iraq invasion, No End in Sight (2007). There one was treated to footage of a pack of fools of the first magnitude: President Bush, Donald Rumsfeld, L. Paul Bremer, whose collective misreading of the situation they would create by invading Iraq, and whose decisions on how to conduct the aftermath of their "victory" in 2003, went beyond mere arrogance and criminal indifference and shameful mismanagement to become a kind of psychotic episode in American history, worse than any previous misstep, such as Vietnam, because of the degree to which it was masterminded in so slipshod a manner and ramrodded down the public's throat with such cynical aplomb. Footage of Rumsfeld glibly bantering at press conference after press conference -- "I don't do quagmires" -- would be funny if it weren't so galling. Ferguson's film relies upon thirtysome informants, most of whom were part of the initial attempt to restore order after the period of rampant looting had already taken its toll, but who were mostly summarily dismissed under the baleful malfeasance of Bremer, at whose door the film lays the major gaffes in the form of decisions that reflect an attempt to clean house of any Saddamites, but which in the process simply laid the groundwork for an insurgency against the U.S. Valuable for its hindsight appraisal of everything that went wrong, the film plays a bit too heavily on the headshaking and handwringing of those whose intentions seemed to be good (not ideologically against the war on principle, they were eager to do the job that, they believed, American presence in the region should accomplish: stability and human resources). The story is dramatic, frustrating, with a kind of black humor tone occasionally creeping in. As with any complete breakdown of bureaucracy (New Orleans and Katrina comes to mind), the statements of those who were on hand while it was going down always sound surreal: parties to a grand loss of rational procedure and the leaders' monomaniac insistence on "their" people, they can only act as witness to a grand folly. The effect is to make the viewer a kind of righteous fool, suddenly puffed up with anger at the series of debacles that have been U.S. policy in the 60 plus years since WWII.

In terms of my own claim to "fool" status, I undertook a task of rearranging single-handedly my writing, reading and music room, which is to say that I had to transplant hundreds of books, CDs, LPs, and a rather cumbersome desk. The task continues as I find that for some reason my DSL connection has been affected by its brief disconnection. The height of feeling foolish in this regard occurs when one tries to get an answer from an actual knowledgeable human when dealing with the mysterious entity known as AT&T and its various robots and recordings and frustratingly uninformative websites. I find myself repeating to myself Wilson's mantra from the conclusion of 1984 like any good fool should, sanguine at the degree to which he is happy to live in a brave new world depleted of responsibility and answerability, but relentless in its pursuit of "connectivity."

A few more fools: at the WHC on Friday night (the 11th) I watched for the first time a Charlie Chaplin film on the big screen. It was Monsieur Verdoux (1947), an uncharacteristic role for Chaplin, as a sympathetic Bluebeard figure (laid-off bank clerk) with multiple wives who he kills off or tries to kill off one by one so as to support his lifestyle with his true wife and son. The film runs on too long and has too many inconsequential scenes, but what never flags is the charisma of Chaplin himself. He's one of those people who seems to exist to be on film, and his acting isn't overly histrionic (except for a few broad comic turns), nor is it the motivated style of today. It's a kind of relentless exploration of mannerism for the sake of effect. Which is to say that it's a kind of acting that communicates to the audience that it knows it's being watched. The year the film opened, Woody Allen turned twelve. I have no doubt he saw it then. It explains a lot.

Finally, I got around to watching Godard's Pierrot le Fou (1965) on DVD. There are plenty of amusing throwaway lines, but the film seems to lie somewhere between A bout de souffle (1959) and Weekend (1967) in its haphazard run-through of genres that never quite jell. The fact that they aren't meant to doesn't do all that much to keep it moving, unlike the far more nimble and caustically satiric Weekend. Pierrot has many of the usual Godard tropes -- brooding Belmondo with his eternal cigarette, fetching Karina (who occasionally makes the film a musical), car accidents that look like modern art, guns and guerillas and the Vietnam and Algerian wars, withdrawal from modern life in an idyllic setting on the Meditteranean, murky plot points involving gangsters, text on screen and voice over readings, references to other films -- La Dolce Vita (1960), in one comic moment -- and moments that seem to point to Bonnie and Clyde (1967) for which Godard was considered as a possible director, and self-referential moments toward cinema itself, but they too often drag rather than dance. But then, I never seem to enjoy Godard when I watch him at home. Foolish to try, I suppose.

Friday, March 7, 2008

CINEMATIC SUBLIME

Last Friday night the WHC featured the films of Nathaniel Dorsky, an avant-garde filmmaker whose career began in 1964. The four films I saw comprise a series that Dorsky made from 1996 to 2001, collectively entitled “Cinematic Songs”: Triste, Variations, Arbor Vitae, Love’s Refrain. All four, shot in 16mm and shown at 18fps rather than the 24fps of sound film, follow much the same format: silent, no soundtrack, comprised of discrete shots or brief clips that have no direct continuity with one another. Watching the films is at times like watching a slide show in which the subjects of the individual slides move and the slides vary in their duration and during which the camera can move. And of course the switch from shot to shot creates juxtapositions, “sequences” of a sort. But there is no narrative, no logical connection between scenes.

The images themselves are fascinating, beautiful, compelling: a plastic bag blowing at random over a space of sidewalk, buildings dissolving in the penumbra of tree branches shaking in gusts of wind, rain on surfaces, on windows, light, of all kinds in all places, animals appearing suddenly in their gestalt purity, cars moving in slow motion or, in one lovely, estranging sequence, shown in negative crossing a bridge, street scenes, street crossings, umbrellas, trains, an almost dreamlike sequence in which one contemplates the shadow of an overhead train as it passes over a network of girders below -- one shot particularly striking is from above some people on an ocean overlook while a long, beautifully formed wave streams into the scene converting the water’s surface to foam: it’s not simply that the wave does its job well and is wonderfully picturesque; the foreground of lights and darks where a few figures look over the wall or walk along the walkway glows with late daylight and the angle of the shot is such that the wave extends beyond the frame above and the wall below. There are any number of moments like this. Time and again Dorsky shows himself a master of framing, of depth of field. Another favorite was an insect crawling along a garden hose that is running. The shot is in closeup and the hose and the water seem to form an unbroken continuity except that one part is solid and one part is in motion, emptying to the right of the screen. Enter the insect from the left, crawling, as we watch fascinated, toward the tip of the hose only to stop just at the threshold between solid and liquid.

The visual poetry of these films is like nothing I’ve ever seen in movies, to this extent, and the sheer visual pleasure they afford struck me in two ways: in the first place, it made me think of my own engagement with the visual properties of the world. I found myself contemplating how one first experienced light on water, shadows on surfaces, rain, insects, birds in flight or walking, cars and other shiny objects as reflective surfaces; the films seemed to bring to mind the mind of a child, simply fascinated by what he sees because he is seeing. There needs no explanation or excuse for looking, for watching light change, or, as it were, grass grow. The level of fascination one finds in the images Dorsky records I think has to do with one’s ability to recall those initial moments of wonder in the face of the world’s variety of color, movement, shape, illumination.

Then there’s the second thought that occupied me at various times: why is it that cinema, as it is generally practiced, is so incapable of such contemplative moments of pure imagery, of just letting the camera run to catch the light of day, the signs of the weather, the actual flora and fauna of the setting -- those things that poets attest to the sublimity of time and again, and which was once the province of the brush of the representational painter, willing to make the viewer stand in a certain place and see a view of the world? Why are our images so often at the service of story?

As one who was always able to stand long and rapt before amazing handling of paint as a rendering of light, and who was disappointed by cameras that never seemed able to render the subtlety the eye is capable of, and who has always appreciated random moments and shots in narrative films that serve no particular purpose but simply give us something memorable to look at, I am grateful to Dorsky for these films, and to the Film Study Program at WHC for showing them.

Elle est retouvée!
-- Quoi? -- l’Eternité.
C’est la mer mêlée
Au soleil.
–Rimbaud

Thursday, February 28, 2008

HOW THE WEST WAS ONE, 3

Finally this brings me to the two Westerns paired last Friday at the WHC: My Darling Clementine and Paris, Texas, films separated by more than 40 years of film-making, with a difference of style and substance obvious enough to make clear that the way in which they are comparable has to do with an almost archetypal sense of the hero as a figure committed to a change of the status quo. His is an intervention made necessary by circumstances; though how that intervention plays out has not much in common, there is a noticeable kinship in the films’ iconic structure: hero emerges from the wasteland, rights certain wrongs, rides off into the distance, in both cases leaving behind a woman.

In Clementine there is a promise to return; in Paris, no such expectation – and that can be said to be a major difference in the two men and their respective situations as heroes. Henry Fonda, as Wyatt Earp, gives us a tense, knowing hero, a man committed to his own vision of what is right – which means not only that he will avenge his brothers’ deaths, but will also do right by the town, Tombstone, to the best of his ability. He’s a lawman in that self-reliant and carefully modulated way that inspires respect. His courtship of Clementine (Cathy Downs), who comes to Tombstone in search of Doc Holliday (Victor Mature), boasts the kind of restraint generally found among knights enacting a code of chivalry as a self-effacing version of heroism – something almost wholly missing amidst the show-boating, wise-cracking heroes to which we’ve become accustomed, from Harrison Ford to Bruce Willis to the various Bonds and whoever else is generally cast as a good guy taking arms against a sea of troubles and threats.

What’s amusing is that Harry Dean Stanton’s Travis Henderson in Paris is cut from that same “strong, silent type” mold, only moreso. If Henry “yup” Fonda is laconic, Stanton is literally mute in the film’s early going. Even after he starts talking again, his voice is low, dispassionate, firm but not deep or assertive. In fact what most impresses as masculine in his character is his willingness to play the fool, if necessary, to get the attention, and eventually allegiance, of his estranged son, Hunter, a young boy who has grown to about 8 or 9 without knowing his father. Stanton manages something that most of our loner, badass heroes rarely manage: a camaraderie with a child. In the John Wayne Westerns I spoke of earlier, we see much of the generational clash – the older man’s testing of the younger man, the younger man’s bid for respect. But to see the father figure working for the son’s respect and acceptance is in many ways truer to the times we’ve lived through since, not simply in the proliferation of “dead beat dads,” but in the sense of an older generation that “went off the rails,” so to speak – if not literally wandering in the desert like Travis, then at least wandering spiritually away from the kind of fixity and secure fortunes that “the West” has always cast doubt upon, from the time of the settling of its wildness, to the Gold Rush, to the Siren Song of Hollywood (“any mechanic can be a panic”) to the era, perhaps still not wholly eclipsed, of its “get here and we’ll do the rest” come-on to the nomadic drop-out subculture of the 60s and 70s. To emerge from four years of wandering in a 1984 film is to say that the 70s are over . . .

But, to return to the topic I began this trilogy of comments with, what of the relation of these men, however heroic their status or mundane their comportment, to their women? Fonda’s Earp is a romantic hero in the sense of one who knows “the real thing” when he sees it: he never doubts his feelings for Clementine, even though she is at first fixated on the fickle and ailing Doc. But the book-ends of Earp’s revenge play against the callous rancher Old Man Clanton (Walter Brennan) and his courtship of Clementine is a period with his brothers in the wilderness as cattle-drivers, and a return to the wilderness to bear the tidings of the family’s loss to their father. In other words, his trajectory is a bit Biblical and, if God’s in his heaven, Earp’s path will lead him back to his true love. But it may be that untold adventures await and the settling down – the accepted union that is clearly prepared for Matt Garth in Red River or for Martin Pawley in The Searchers – could be denied indefinitely. Earp, in other words, is still a man with a mission, and “woman” is perhaps a prize at the end of one’s necessary tasks, a goal or object for the end of action, not a cause of action.

It’s hard to imagine what Travis’ mission is once he has brought his son and his missing former wife together again. There are ways, no doubt, to read him as a symbolic figure of fate, a way of saying that the time is up on this unnatural sundering of mother and child and only a dogged hero, obeying convictions born during his sojourn in the desert, can effect that change. But the film also gives us elements that work against this romantic heroism: the settled and unremarkable family life in which Hunter lives with Travis’ brother and his wife – the disruption of this world is clearly for the sake of something, but what that is the film doesn’t really help us recognize. It’s Travis’ conviction that his son and the boy’s mother should be reunited, but it was Jane (Natassia Kinski) who surrendered the boy to her in-laws, and, though she sends them money for Hunter, she keeps her distance (in Houston, while the boy lives in Los Angeles).

In other words, playwright Sam Shepard’s script gives us a situation where, for some reason never made clear, only a male, paternalistic solution is possible. And we also have no basis for understanding why Jane and Hunter can live together happily ever after now, but couldn’t before Travis returned, only to leave again. We have to accept, in old archetypal Western fashion, that women and children and ineffectual common folk (like Travis’ brother, played by Dean Stockwell) can’t overcome their own inertia and lack of grit. We can almost hear them mutter “who was that masked man” as Travis rides off in his beat-up truck-bed Caddy. Much as I admire the film and Travis’ long monologue to Jane on a phone, separated from her by a one-way glass, I’m always brought up short by the script’s inability or unwillingness (for it amounts to the same thing) to imagine a role for Kinski. She listens mutely and accepting to the version of their history that Travis describes, but what her life was or is now is left to hang as though, at some profound level, she needed only to be given meaning again by Travis’ intervention.

Which is to say that, in the 40 years between My Darling Clementine and Paris, Texas, the West can become a state of mind a man carries within him, but it borders on a self-fulfillment fantasy – one that Hollywood films will continue to try to sell in various forms and occasionally interrogate (Clint Eastwood’s The Unforgiven, 1992) – that leads, perhaps inevitably, to a “sins of the father” struggle in which the foundational crime – as Prof. Pippin emphasized in his discussion of Red River and Tom’s departure from the wagon train and the woman who loves him – is leaving the women out.

Tuesday, February 26, 2008

HOW THE WEST WAS ONE, 2

The point, as I see it, is that the West as Hollywood gives it to us is forever caught up with the iconic images of its heroes. And that fact is the theme of The Assassination of Jesse James. For this study of male bonding and rivalry finds its focus in what was always an underlying assumption of the Hollywood Western: that the fame of the Old West -- for figures such as Jesse James, Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, Billy the Kid, and so on -- extends in an unbroken line to the fame of Western film stars such as Tom Mix, John Wayne, Clint Eastwood. In other words, the myth of the West is perpetuated in Hollywood as its own birthright, and only rarely does the story of "how the West was won" extend to a consideration of "how the West was one": in the sense of always male and always about fame and proving oneself -- for a woman sometimes, but mainly to and for other men.

I would've liked to attend the screening of and Prof. Pippin's lecture on The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance because I'm sure the film would have offered interesting points of comparison to The Assassination -- because both are concerned with actual legendary killings. But I'm pretty sure (I need to see The Man again to test this) that the Wayne persona again places a certain whimsy at the heart of the tale. The Assassination limits -- to its strength -- that comradely ribbing that inhabits every Wayne Western: Jesse (Brad Pitt) is a loner, essentially, though he always works with a gang, but that gang, though indulging in "the band of brothers" mentality when it suits, is always uneasy with their role as his henchmen and, like any "band of thieves," is always ready to look squarely at the advantage to be found in betrayal.

The complexity of the tale comes in the character of Robert Ford (Casey Affleck) who is infatuated with Jesse, not so much as a man, but as a living legend, as the stuff of which his own dreams of glory is made. We're clearly away from the Oedipal struggle, or the struggle of Abraham and Isaac, or even the struggle of Cain and Abel and into the realm of Jesus and Judas, but the film doesn't make that comparison overly explicit, if only because Jesse, whether as family man or outlaw, is never perceived by anyone but Ford as a mythic being. Rather than Biblical archetypes, the film is more firmly rooted in American betrayals: in Ford's expectation that he would be canonized for his killing of the outlaw we hear echoes of how John Wilkes Booth expected a hero's welcome in the South for the killing of Lincoln, and in the public killing of Ford by a man who simply took it upon himself to do it, there is a forerunner of Jack Ruby, the assassin of another famous assassin.

Suffice to say that what makes The Assassination interesting -- besides its stately pace, highly literate voice-over narration, and finely nuanced performance by Affleck in a role he perfectly suits -- is the sense that the male world of the West is ultimately about a relation to history, to fable, to the tales we tell of the men in a man's world who make a difference, who seize the moment. Freed of the sentimental attachment to camaraderie that infuses the world of Wayne and Ward Bond, or Wayne and Walter Brennan, The Assassination is a more somber affair in which there really isn't anyone to like or to root for.

Such a notion of the Western was anathema to Ford and Hawks and Wayne and Eastwood and its lesser practitioners, but for that very reason the film is refreshing. It would be easy to imagine a Western à la George Clooney's Ocean films with the usual banter among guys being cute and cut-throat by turns, as the situation demands, but The Assassination is not after our entertaining sense of the Old West and of Hollywood as mutually supportive myths, it's after that darker side of American celebrity where the Booths and Oswalds and Mark David Chapmans reside, waiting to burst into history for committing the unthinkable act of vengeance against their own obscurity by bringing down the fortunate son, the maker of history, to make of the born leader the dead martyr. Ford, unlike those other assassins, does become his victim's friend and companion and, Judas-like, most deliberate "follower," but etched on his face at every moment is "the coward"'s ambition -- to overcome his status as a non-entity by, first, recognition from his hero and then, when it becomes clear that the hero -- a remorseless murderer when his designs require it -- will soon do away with Ford and his brother, by putting on the mantle of fame as "the man" who ended the life behind the fabled name.

Given that the Oscars just aired last night and that there seems a general consensus, voiced perhaps most emphatically by David Carr in the NYTimes, that the films nominated were somber and lacking in the charms generally associated with blockbuster Hollywood, it might be worth remarking that The Assassination, as a Western, doesn't do what is expected, and that may be true of a number of the films this year. So perhaps there has been recently an eclipse of what Hollywood is best noted for: on the one hand its willingness to be mawkish and bathetic in grand tear-jerker style, on the other its gusto for smart-alecky, winking insouciance. Banter of any sort was almost entirely missing from the dramas nominated for Best Picture, and banter was all Juno had to offer. The writers had been on strike till recently and film-making came to a stop, but it seems that a certain kind of film-making, Tinseltown's most identifiable product, has ceased for want of writers equal to the task. After all, it may be hard to use the tried-and-true methods to tell "how the west was lost."

Sunday, February 24, 2008

HOW THE WEST WAS ONE

The West is a manly place, that's the conclusion I've come to after watching this week several different kinds of Westerns made in different eras -- two by John Ford: My Darling Clementine (1946) and The Searchers (1956), one -- Paris, Texas (1984) -- by the German director Wim Wenders, set in the '80s, and one from last year: made by Andrew Dominick, an Australian director, it's the film of a novel on the relationship between two famous figures of the Old West: The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford. To this list, I'll add Howard Hawks' Big River (1948), which was featured in the first Castle lecture last Monday given by Robert B. Pippin of University of Chicago on that film's theme of male rivalry -- seemingly Oedipal, in this case -- and of the male bonds that constitute the construction of the West, bonds which seem to be the point of the entire conception of the West as cinema gives it to us, with women not so much a prize as an afterthought, nor so much an afterthought as a conceptual reference point -- something implied, even by absence, rather than present; something sought, rather than kept; something valued, if largely avoided.

In Pippin's discussion, the relation between Tom Dunson (John Wayne) and Matt Garth (Monty Clift) in Red River set up a generational struggle which is unusual for the fact that it transpires entirely in a male world -- there is no mother at stake as in the traditional Oedipal story. Matt, a foundling, manages to claim his "birthright" from patriarch Dunson after a struggle that is not to the death, as the film threatens, but is instead broken up by Matt's future wife who threatens them with a gun and sobs "you both love each other, anyone can see that." It's not only that the scene is hokey, badly acted (by Colleen Gray), and a happy Hollywood ending, it's also that it conforms to the Wayne persona of irascible maleness: first hard-hearted, then nearly a half-mad, wrathful Ahab figure, finally a loveable old coot. The story Pippin wants the film to tell is the film before it reverts to Wayne-schtick with Clift as wonderstruck sidekick (he reminded me of Owen Wilson at the end).

John Wayne, as a star, can't be made to conform to what the story requires -- this is again the case in The Searchers, which was screened after the lecture, where Wayne's character, Ethan Edwards, is a driven man with a definite task: to avenge the death of his relatives at the hands of Comanche, but also to kill his niece Debbie (Natalie Wood) when he learns that she has become a Comanche squaw. In other words, the female role -- as in traditional tribal cultures -- is a means of exchange. If a woman is taken forcibly and "converted" to another race's ways, then she doesn't deserve to live. This is the ethical code of Ethan -- but not the code of John Wayne, who embraces the girl at the end after she has agreed to be rescued by Martin Pawley (Jeffrey Hunter), her adopted brother, a halfbreed who antagonizes Ethan by tagging along but who also gets his "birthright" when Ethan bequeaths all his possessions to him.

In both films, the strong male figure, a maverick played by Wayne, softens toward the handsome young ephebe and eventually blesses him. In Red River, he also is impressed by a woman's love for Matt; in The Searchers, his niece is at first vilified then accepted, and much of the humor of the film is the romantic interest of the not-so-patiently waiting Laurie (a young and plucky Vera Miles) who gets to be the object of a brawl between her suitors. But the film's close is the return of Debbie to the homestead, not the successful courtship. The strength of Miles' pioneer woman -- passionate and focused -- is a good foil to the dogged, "aw shucks" persona of Martin, but the film is never really a story of settling down. It's a male movie that treats the fortunes of frontier lovers as comic relief and finds in woman the traditional status of victim, then damsel in distress, then returned prodigal -- only briefly is the possibility of Debbie as a brave new harbinger of an inter-racial America glanced at, and the film's myopia toward the Native Americans is possibly most overt in the comic and then tragic figure of "Look," the Indian squaw who attaches herself to Martin and is eventually killed in a raid by white rangers.

I dislike finding myself in the position of offering those tired standards of "the other" -- race and gender -- as positions from which to condemn the white male ethic of these movies, and I think both movies do more than simply perpetuate assumptions about how people who aren't upstanding white men deserve to be treated (in The Searchers the only other enemy besides the Indians is the Jew Futterman who tries to double-cross Ethan), they also give us a view of the West as the province of a certain kind of male ethic that -- in each film -- has something to learn. But the reason, I feel, that the viewer doesn't learn as well is that both films play the hand dealt by the John Wayne Old West Machine: the necessity of the "let bygones be bygones" ending that both Red River and The Searchers indulge so as to allow Wayne to keep his n'er do wrong persona intact, instead of confronting the viewer with the hard fact of the sins of the fathers in their intransigent claim to authority, racial purity, white right, and freedom from petticoat government.

Enough for now. As Ethan would say, "put an Amen to it!" To be continued...

Sunday, February 3, 2008

RIVETING RIVETTE

From a literary work that can be read in about four hours, let's turn to a film that takes about four hours to view: Jacques Rivette's L'amour fou (1969) which the WHC screened a week ago. Watching the film is an interesting experience if only because anything you do for four hours at a stretch is bound to create a certain kind of self-awareness.

The film's naturalism is relentless, an almost documentary-like insistence on what "really" happens. This is particularly the case in the 16mm footage from a camera crew filming the rehearsals for a rather offhand, method-acted version of Racine's Andromaque. That idea alone is sufficiently daunting (at one point Sébastien, the play's director and the film's principle protagonist, muses that the actors are learning to speak the alexandrines as though they aren't alexandrines -- and it's true: the lines from the play rarely sound like Racine) to make the rehearsals somewhat interesting. Also, however it's managed by Rivette, the rehearsals feel like real rehearsals, not so much due to the acting of the actors in the play (who really aren't very good at being on stage), but because of Jean-Pierre Kalfon (Sébastien) who enacts so artlessly the role of director -- a director who, we feel, is only finding his footing by watching the rehearsals unfold. In fact, at various times he loses his footing -- the rehearsals limp along with no definitive readings or scenes taking place -- but Kalfon remains engaging because he seems so dedicated to an idea of performance that his cast is only groping toward.

Set against this process of possible discovery is Sébastien's loss of his wife Claire (Bulle Ogier) who is first engaged to play the part of Hermione. She quits the play and remains for a time as a kind of muse to her director husband, but when Marta, a former girlfriend, is contacted to play the role she has abdicated, the strain on the relationship of the couple becomes progressively more manifest.

What's particularly interesting is the way that this gradual dissolution of the couple plays itself out -- it begins to become dramatically more significant than the play towards the end of the first two hours, with Claire becoming somewhat amusingly flighty and moody (as for instance in her sudden effort to procure a certain kind of dog admired by her husband because its sad face reminds him of her), and with Sébastien attempting, in his sweetly diffident way, to work his charm on Marta. After the intermission, the stress of Claire's depression begins to take its toll on Sébastien -- without his knowing it, she impulsively contacts a former friend and has uninspired sex with him simply to be unfaithful to her husband. The tensions in their married life are presented with a kind of naked and deliberate absorption, but without any of the melodrama that most tales of marital strife wallow in. Rivette is able to register with amazing fidelity the simple, deliberate torture of two people living together when they've ceased to have any common ground -- in desire, affection, interests -- to reference together.

But the great triumph of the film is in the scenes in which Sébastien and Claire reunite -- Sébastien calls his assistant at the theater and says he'll be away for a few days, when instead he and Claire take to their bedroom and let themselves go in childlike abandonment to sex and high-spirited silliness -- drawing all over each other and the bedroom wallpaper, breaking through a door separating their bedroom and living-room, redecorating the latter as a kind of seraglio -- that lets us glimpse for the first time what the couple might have been like to begin with (when we first meet them the problem of the play and with Claire's decision to quit is already present).

What has emerged by the time we reach their orgy of togetherness is a sense of Sébastien having to grow by trying his ideas on the play, and of Claire trying to find a way to compete with his dedication to the rehearsals, or a way to replace his importance in her life. In other words, she seems a woman driven by a kind of gnawing resentment -- of the cast, of her husband's involvement, of his former girlfriend -- who places herself "on stage" within the couple's domestic space, providing cues and situations that Sébastien is expected to read and respond to. When he is unresponsive, she retaliates by going him one better till she seems nothing but a blank and silent mannequin in his presence. Then comes the revelation of joy and humor of the two together -- which ends with Claire's final withdrawal and, after her departure, Sébastien's inability to continue with the play. The drama of their lives -- "l'amour fou" between them is effectively portrayed, riveting for the most part, but only because the nuances are so close to unmannered, artless behavior (not performance) -- has superseded "l'amour fou" of Racine's grand tragedy, which never catches fire with the cast as they have found no way to translate its passionate rhetoric into effective performance.

The lesson seems to be that art is no consolation and that love -- its presence or its absence a state of being -- can only be lived, not acted.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

DANSE MACABRE

In NYC on Monday I attended a revival screening of Alain Resnais’ Last Year at Marienbad (1961). It’s probably only the second or third time I’ve seen the film in a theater, though I’ve watched it on tape at least once and on DVD once. My uncertainty as to how many times I’ve viewed it seems related thematically to the film itself and to the fact that the world it depicts may or may not be happening, or may or may not have already happened, or may or may not be about to happen. There’s no film that so effectively suspends one’s sense of the determinate sequence of a story; not even those films that play with alternate versions of the present or alternative constructions of the past – films like Mulholland Drive and Memento come to mind – convey as relentlessly the sense of not knowing where or when we are. And this is in part because, to my mind, Resnais and the scriptwriter Alain Robbe-Grillet never quite let us settle on watching the story unfold; they never let the characters – as people – overcome our sense of the characters as “figures,” chesspieces, perhaps, moving statues, perhaps, talking pictures, certainly.

Following that idea, we could say that the film meditates on film itself – on our willingness to surrender to the dream of movies which has supplanted the willingness to surrender to narratives, whether written or oral – and delivers to us not only the fact of how our experience of what we see is controlled by conventions that the knowing filmmaker can distort to a variety of effects, but also the fact that, psychologically, we are always to some extent spectators of our own psyches as though at the movies, that the world of our dreams includes us and excludes us simultaneously because the “us” we find there is a composite, a story in the conditional, an “as if” or “what if” of “our” own making. Marienbad delivers that sense of the dream /film that at first only vaguely implicates us, even as it seems to be following a kind of inexorable logic that it offers us to follow or interpret. As we do begin to play its game, as we do allow ourselves to respond to the formal rigor of “this enormous, luxurious, baroque, lugubrious hotel” as setting, to the beauty of the waspish Delphine Seyrig as the woman, to the distraught insistence of the man (Giorgio Albertazzi), to the unsettling horror movie organ tones, to the fluid tracking shots, to the trompe l’oeils of backgrounds and foregrounds and shadows or their lack, to the snatches of conversation that comment on the action as though spoken by movie-goers, to the alterations in white and black in the woman’s bedroom, to the cadaverous expression of the woman’s current male companion and his uncanny ability to win the matchstick game every time, to the distortions of film treatment, we are drawn into the dream, we begin to have memories of the previous repetition that are impacted by the new version. We are sleuths in search of the "evidence": the image or sequence that will register for each of us uniquely as "key."

Long ago a friend characterized the film as “like being in purgatory,” and that’s not simply a fortuitous comparison. The film enacts purgatory as a space in which figures who seem vaguely to know one another, to share a past or the possibility of a future, meet in a series of scenes that are nonlinear, propelled by – as is generally the case in Robbe-Grillet’s fiction – a restless sense that the elimination of possible permutations will at some point necessarily veer off into the truth, or that the accumulation of versions will exhaust all possible permutations, leaving us with a story that is fully, finally told, if never resolved. My sense watching the film this time was that the husband or companion of the woman, who suspects that his wife is desired by and perhaps desirous of the man, was in many scenes a death figure, his presence suggesting the extent to which the inhabitants of this hotel were present there for all eternity with “no exit.”

But that sense mainly comes through in the first half of the movie when the relationships are less clear; once the movie begins to opt for some version of the infidelity plot it begins to be more reasonable, less a reverie, but even so the idea that the woman and the man are finally leaving together, that she has responded to his importuning and accepted that they really did meet and have an affair “last year at Marienbad,” is suspended in that final shot of the darkened hotel which seems to offer itself as the only place where the couple can exist, corresponding to a certain area of one’s own mind or memory where a strong sense of what could have been or should have been remains to burn on, even after death -- peut-être, as the woman would say.

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

GOTTA DANCE!

The WHC Film Series kicked off the new semester Friday with a screening of Singin' in the Rain (1952), one of the most celebrated films of all time -- at least by those for whom motion pictures are, at some level, synonymous with entertainment. It's often remarked that the Oscars favor drama and "serious" films, and that comedies and musicals get less respect. That's so, as a general rule, but then it's rare for a comedy or musical really to transcend the limitations of the genre. What limitations? Well, for one, the tendency to be silly or cartoonish or parodic. Singin' is all those things, but it still shines because it wears its limitations with utter insouciance. It can afford to because it bases its appeal on the old idea of talent being its own reward, but it also presents talent as the only commodity that ultimately matters in show biz. As such it's a show biz parable that never ceases to be applicable -- yes, it's the standard "a star is born" scenario, but, the film insists, being a star is not a question of means (how to work the system) but a question of ends (how to give the people what they want when what they want is genuine talent).

The appeal of Hollywood in the '20s is that it has no traditions yet. So it's the place where those with show-biz talent can land when vaudeville and Broadway become dead-ends. Hollywood is depicted as silly and benign -- it's a '50s view of the '20s, able to appreciate its energy and style while able to smirk at its pretensions and quaintness. And for happy-go-lucky smirking there's no one better than Gene Kelly. As our hero he exudes charm, vulnerability, brio, and a kind of guy next door normality that goes a long way to make him believable as the dancing Everyman, the kind who makes it all look easy as breathing. And for comic exuberance there's no one like Donald O'Connor who mugs gleefully and walks up walls and wrestles with dummies and delivers fast comebacks with Groucho-esque timing. Which leaves Debbie Reynolds as the gal who's practically one of the guys, gifted with the ability to blend perfectly with the one-two punch of Kelly and O'Connor. The feel-good numbers "Good Mornin'" and "Singin' in the Rain" work (i.e., you actually feel good) -- and what's more the whole notion of "Singin' in the Rain" comes more and more to seem emblematic of a devil-may-care optimism that seems uniquely American -- no matter what kind of shit-storm is going on or how far DOW plunges.

The plot of the star whose voice is a travesty of her romantic image was true to some careers that couldn't weather the transition to "talkies," but the character gets a bit tiresome, as do some of the romantic numbers. But the opportunity to have fun at the movies in such a relentlessly wholesome way is rare, and the glimpse of a quaint older era's take -- in terms of gender and romance and what to poke fun at -- on a quaint era even older seems to become more priceless, more worthy of preservation the further we go from that post-WWII, pre-Vietnam era. It's a time when adults could enjoy movies that made them feel young without having to feel that youth had its own ax to grind or its own arcane sense of what was 'cool' or 'hip' or 'real.'

One of the perks of seeing the film with a packed house of mostly undergrads is that the enthusiastic applause after Donald O'Connor's numbers and when the film ended added a kind of reassuring promotion of the film's credo: physical legerdemain to music exerts an almost timeless fascination, the more so because the dancing is only occasionally choreographed as arty or expressive. Primarily it's presented as pure spectacle -- something which you have to turn to animation to find in films these days. The '50s were hardly the Golden Age of cinema, but the period did produce a few notable entertainments "for the whole family": the kind of film Ozzie and Harriet could see with the Nelson boys, or her TV parents with Gidget. Everyone's a clown, everyone can sing (except that evil glamour queen), and everyone can dance!